PlanOptica
CompaniesPricing
Sign inTry Pro free
Try Pro free
  1. Companies/
  2. Merchants Mutual Insurance Company
  • Benefits analytics
  • Plan summaries
  • Retirement plans
  • Health & Benefits plans

Filings through Oct 24, 2026.

Top hat

Merchants Mutual Insurance Company

EIN 16-0550140-insurance-Latest filing 2025
Plans
3
Retirement
1
$84.1M assets
Health & Benefits
2
$5.4M premiums
Participants
1,354
250 MAIN STREET - BUFFALO, NY 14202716-849-3333LinkedIn201-500 employeesinsurance
Plans on this EIN
3 filings
#002401(k)-$84.1M - 440 part#508Fully insured-$5.4M - 440 lives#509Self-funded-0 lives

Health & Benefits portfolio - carriers, brokers and premium across this company's 2 health and benefits plans.

Benefits portfolio analytics

2 plans / $5.4M premiums / 440 covered lives

Coverage by line

Premium dollars by benefit type (bundled lines overlap)

  • Health$4.9M
  • Prescription drug$4.9M
  • Other$303K
  • Life$301K
  • Long-term disability$301K
  • Dental$188K
  • +1 more
Total $5.4M7 rows
See carrier and broker market share with Pro.
Pro unlocks:
  • Top carriers and their premium share
  • Top brokers and their commission share

Plan summaries

Each card links to its plan page. The plan page shows fees vs peers, audit grade, history and counterparties.

Retirement#002

MERCHANTS MUTUAL CAPITAL ACCUMULATION PLAN

401(k)

Assets$84.1M
Participants440
On the plan page
Fees vs peersAudit gradeAsset trajectoryContributionsSch C providers
Open plan
Health & Benefits#508

MERCHANTS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY BENEFIT OPTIONS PLAN

Fully insured - HIGHMARK WESTERN AND NORTHEASTERN NEW YORK INC.

Premiums$5.4M
Covered lives440
On the plan page
Premium breakdownCarriersBrokersCoverage stats
Open plan
Health & Benefits#509

MERCHANTS MUTUAL SEVERANCE PAY PLAN

Self-funded

Premiums$0
Covered lives0
On the plan page
Premium breakdownCarriersBrokersCoverage stats
Open plan

Retirement plans

1 plan on this EIN

PlanNameTypeAssetsParticipantsLatest year
#002MERCHANTS MUTUAL CAPITAL ACCUMULATION PLAN401(k)$84.1M4402025
  • MERCHANTS MUTUAL CAPITAL ACCUMULATION PLAN$84.1M
    #002 · 401(k) · 2025440

Health & Benefits plans

2 plans on this EIN

PlanNameFundingCarrierPremiumsCoveredLatest year
#508MERCHANTS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY BENEFIT OPTIONS PLANFully insuredHIGHMARK WESTERN AND NORTHEASTERN NEW YORK INC.$5.4M4402025
#509MERCHANTS MUTUAL SEVERANCE PAY PLANSelf-funded-$002025
  • MERCHANTS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY BENEFIT OPTIONS PLAN$5.4M
    #508 · Fully insured · HIGHMARK WESTERN AND NORTHEASTERN NEW YORK INC. · 2025440
  • MERCHANTS MUTUAL SEVERANCE PAY PLAN$0
    #509 · Self-funded · 20250
Retirement plans
Health & Benefits plans

On this page

  1. Benefits analytics
  2. Plan summaries
  3. Retirement plans
  4. Health & Benefits plans
PlanOptica

Advisors and brokers use PlanOptica to research retirement and health plans. Each plan has 10 years of filings, a peer rank and a source for every number.

Product
  • Retirement
  • Health & Benefits
  • Funds & Managers
  • Companies
  • Pricing
Data
  • Downloads
  • Retirement plans CSV
  • Health & Benefits plans CSV
  • Plan holdings CSV
  • Custom analysis
  • API and AI agents
Resources
  • Free ERISA search
  • Free EIN lookup
  • All providers
  • Health & Benefits providers
  • Filter catalog
  • Documentation
  • Glossary
  • Compare
Company
  • About
  • Research
  • Press
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
© 2026 PlanOptica