PlanOptica
CompaniesPricing
Sign inTry Pro free
Try Pro free
  1. Companies/
  2. Preferred Mutual Insurance Company
  • Retirement analytics
  • Benefits analytics
  • Plan summaries
  • Retirement plans
  • Health & Benefits plans

Filings through Oct 24, 2026.

Top hat

Preferred Mutual Insurance Company

EIN 15-0420080-insurance-Latest filing 2025
Plans
6
Retirement
2
$107.1M assets
Health & Benefits
4
$4.3M premiums
Participants
2,139
ONE PREFERRED WAY - NEW BERLIN, NY 134110000607-847-6161preferredmutual.comLinkedIn201-500 employeesinsurance
Plans on this EIN
6 filings
#003401(k)-$56.8M - 403 part#001Cash balance-$50.3M - 502 part#512Fully insured-$3.9M - 247 lives#508Fully insured-$200K - 250 lives#516Fully insured-$142K - 400 lives#509Fully insured-$81K - 320 lives

Health & Benefits portfolio - carriers, brokers and premium across this company's 4 health and benefits plans.

Retirement portfolio analytics

2 plans aggregated / $107.1M assets / 905 participants

Assets by plan

Share of aggregate retirement assets

  • PROFIT SHARING PLAN (#003)$56.8M
  • BENEFIT ACCUMULATION PLAN (#001)$50.3M
Total $107.1MSelect a row to open it

Recordkeeper share

DC plan assets by Schedule C recordkeeper

Entrenched
  • (Not disclosed)$56.8M
  • FIDELITY INVESTMENTS INSTITUTIONAL$50.3M
Total $107.1MSelect a row to open it

Participants by plan

Active + retired + deferred vested

  • BENEFIT ACCUMULATION PLAN (#001)502
  • PROFIT SHARING PLAN (#003)403
Total 905Select a row to open it

Benefits portfolio analytics

4 plans / $4.3M premiums / 1,217 covered lives

Coverage by line

Premium dollars by benefit type (bundled lines overlap)

  • Health$3.9M
  • Prescription drug$3.8M
  • Dental$183K
  • Life$142K
  • Other$142K
  • Long-term disability$81K
  • +1 more
Total $4.3M7 rows
See carrier and broker market share with Pro.
Pro unlocks:
  • Top carriers and their premium share
  • Top brokers and their commission share

Plan summaries

Each card links to its plan page. The plan page shows fees vs peers, audit grade, history and counterparties.

Retirement#003

PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY EMPLOYEES' CASH AND DEFERRED SAVINGS PROFIT SHARING PLAN

401(k)

Assets$56.8M
Participants403
On the plan page
Fees vs peersAudit gradeAsset trajectoryContributionsSch C providers
Open plan
Retirement#001

PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY RETIREMENT BENEFIT ACCUMULATION PLAN

Cash balance

Assets$50.3M
Participants502
On the plan page
Fees vs peersAudit gradeAsset trajectoryContributionsSch C providers
Open plan
Health & Benefits#512

PREFERRED MUTUAL MEDICAL BENEFITS

Fully insured - EXCELLUS BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD

Premiums$3.9M
Covered lives247
On the plan page
Premium breakdownCarriersBrokersCoverage stats
Open plan
Health & Benefits#508

PREFERRED MUTUAL DENTAL & VISION PLAN

Fully insured - EXCELLUS BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD

Premiums$200K
Covered lives250
On the plan page
Premium breakdownCarriersBrokersCoverage stats
Open plan
Health & Benefits#516

PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAM

Fully insured - HARTFORD LIFE AND ACCIDENT

Premiums$142K
Covered lives400
On the plan page
Premium breakdownCarriersBrokersCoverage stats
Open plan
Health & Benefits#509

PREFERRED MUTUAL LONG TERM DISABILITY

Fully insured - HARTFORD LIFE AND ACCIDENT

Premiums$81K
Covered lives320
On the plan page
Premium breakdownCarriersBrokersCoverage stats
Open plan

Retirement plans

2 plans on this EIN

PlanNameTypeAssetsParticipantsLatest year
#003PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY EMPLOYEES' CASH AND DEFERRED SAVINGS PROFIT SHARING PLAN401(k)$56.8M4032025
#001PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY RETIREMENT BENEFIT ACCUMULATION PLANCash balance$50.3M5022025
  • PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY EMPLOYEES' CASH AND DEFERRED SAVINGS PROFIT SHARING PLAN$56.8M
    #003 · 401(k) · 2025403
  • PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY RETIREMENT BENEFIT ACCUMULATION PLAN$50.3M
    #001 · Cash balance · 2025502

Health & Benefits plans

4 plans on this EIN

PlanNameFundingCarrierPremiumsCoveredLatest year
#512PREFERRED MUTUAL MEDICAL BENEFITSFully insuredEXCELLUS BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD$3.9M2472025
#508PREFERRED MUTUAL DENTAL & VISION PLANFully insuredEXCELLUS BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD$200K2502025
#516PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAMFully insuredHARTFORD LIFE AND ACCIDENT$142K4002025
#509PREFERRED MUTUAL LONG TERM DISABILITYFully insuredHARTFORD LIFE AND ACCIDENT$81K3202025
  • PREFERRED MUTUAL MEDICAL BENEFITS$3.9M
    #512 · Fully insured · EXCELLUS BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD · 2025247
  • PREFERRED MUTUAL DENTAL & VISION PLAN$200K
    #508 · Fully insured · EXCELLUS BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD · 2025250
  • PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAM$142K
    #516 · Fully insured · HARTFORD LIFE AND ACCIDENT · 2025400
  • PREFERRED MUTUAL LONG TERM DISABILITY$81K
    #509 · Fully insured · HARTFORD LIFE AND ACCIDENT · 2025320
Retirement plans
Health & Benefits plans

On this page

  1. Retirement analytics
  2. Benefits analytics
  3. Plan summaries
  4. Retirement plans
  5. Health & Benefits plans
PlanOptica

Advisors and brokers use PlanOptica to research retirement and health plans. Each plan has 10 years of filings, a peer rank and a source for every number.

Product
  • Retirement
  • Health & Benefits
  • Funds & Managers
  • Companies
  • Pricing
Data
  • Downloads
  • Retirement plans CSV
  • Health & Benefits plans CSV
  • Plan holdings CSV
  • Custom analysis
  • API and AI agents
Resources
  • Free ERISA search
  • Free EIN lookup
  • All providers
  • Health & Benefits providers
  • Filter catalog
  • Documentation
  • Glossary
  • Compare
Company
  • About
  • Research
  • Press
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
© 2026 PlanOptica