Sign up free to preview peer percentile detail
Free accounts unlock saves, downloads, and 3-year history.
Sign up free to preview 6-year trajectory
Free accounts unlock saves, downloads, and 3-year history.
| Provider | Service type | Compensation |
|---|---|---|
Filed as: MASSACHUSETTS MUTUAL LIFE INS. CO Service code 52 · EIN 04-1590850 | Indirect Investment Fees | $32,779 |
Filed as: BARNES DENNING Service code 10 · EIN 31-1119890 | Accounting | $9,400 |
MORGAN STANLEY SMITH BARNEY3 years Filed as: MORGAN STANLEY INS SERVICES INC. Service code 53 | Insurance Commissions | $8,536 |
BENEFIT SOLUTIONS, ETC.1 year Filed as: BENEFIT SOLUTIONS ETC. Service code 13 | Contract Administrator | $5,436 |
BENEFIT SOLUTIONS, ETC.1 year Filed as: BENEFIT SOLUTIONS ETC Service code 13 · EIN 81-3186048 2312 FAR HILLS AVE · DAYOTN, OH 45419 | Contract Administrator | $360 |
Filed as: MORGAN STANLEY INS SERVICES INC Service code 53 · EIN 51-0116113 | Insurance Commissions | $0 |
Participation rate is below 70% (account-balance holders / active employees) - enrollment or auto-enroll opportunity.
Participant contribution per participant is in the bottom quintile of the peer cohort.
Employer contribution per participant is in the bottom quintile of the peer cohort.
Administrative expenses exceed $300 per participant per year - possible fee-review opportunity. (Recordkeeping / audit / legal; excludes investment management.)
Form 5500 reported a failure to timely transmit participant contributions (Schedule H line 4a).
Auditor signed off without reservation - the cleanest possible opinion.
| Metric | This plan | Peer set | Industry | Size |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Avg account balance | $59,946 | $102,661-41.6% | $151,639-60.5% | $66,938-10.4% |
| Participation rate | 25.0% | 85.5%-60.5pp | 87.5%-62.5pp | 69.8%-44.8pp |
| Annual return | -15.46% | -10.81%-4.6pp | 3.34%-18.8pp | 1.58%-17.0pp |
| Employer contribution / active EE | $1,076 | $4,184-74.3% | $6,165-82.5% | $2,545-57.7% |
| Participant deferral / active EE | $2,511 | $6,645-62.2% | $8,363-70.0% | $4,238-40.7% |
| Admin fee / account holder | $676 | $630+7.2% | $11,613-94.2% | $594+13.9% |